The monsters guilty musicals
Kevin: Matilda. A child gaining superpowers in order to protect herself against asshole adults in her life and getting a happy ending? Yeh he has no idea why it’s his favourite. But he does like the revolting children song.
Andrew: Hadestown. He fell in love with the set, but he hasn’t told anyone. He watched it illegally on YouTube bc it came up on his feed and he just … adored it. The ending was tragic enough that he had to take Neil on a sunset drive and just let their finger lace. He’s watched it three times since and sometimes just replays certain scenes in his head
Nicky: Wicked. Someone being shunned their whole life for being different, for being just who they are? Yeh Nicky was pulled in with Glindas outfit and the rest just fell into place
Aaron: legally blonde. He watched it with Kaitlyn but he hadn’t seen the movie before hand so he was experiencing all the plot twists for the first time. He was very expressive when it came to the trial. Kaitlyn was snorting behind her hand the whole time.
Neil: heathers. Lols. Yall can find ur own reason. I just know in my gut this is true.